Why isn’t there a reed aerophone with valves?



Asked by: Michelle Grasso

Brass instruments combine that with vibrating the lips at different speeds so that notes in the harmonic series of any one of those valve combinations are sounded. In contrast, reed aerophones only vibrate best at the resonant frequency of the instrument as it is configured with the current fingering.

Are reed instruments aerophones?





Its use in sophisticated instruments originated in ancient Southeast Asia and reached Europe during the Crusades. Because free-reed instruments cause sound vibrations in unenclosed air, they are classified as free aerophones (as opposed to pipes).

What instrument does not have a reed?

Flute family

The Flute family does not have Reed and it produces the vibration by blowing in its tone hole.

Do any brass instruments have reeds?

Since reeds are absent from brass instruments, there is no trace of wood or reed in brass instruments. Although both types of instruments use a force of air to make a sound, the mouthpiece of woodwind instruments requires a reed while the mouthpiece of brass instruments do not.

What instruments require a reed?





What instruments use reeds? Reeds are used in many wind instruments. Some of the most common are the clarinet, saxophone, oboe, and bassoon. More unusual are instruments that use brass reeds, such as the accordion, and harmonica, not to mention the pipe organ.

Which instruments have valves?

Although the most common instrument to use Rotary Valves is the French Horn, Trumpets, Flugelhorns, Euphoniums, Tubas and other brass instruments are also made in rotary valve variations.

Are flutes made from reeds?

In flutes, the airstream is directed against a sharp edge; in reeds, the air column in the tube is caused to vibrate between beating parts of a multiple reed or between a beating single reed and a mouthpiece. Essential to sound production in reedpipes is the reed itself.

Do all woodwinds use reeds?

All woodwinds produce sound by splitting the air blown into them on a sharp edge, such as a reed or a fipple. Despite the name, a woodwind may be made of any material, not just wood.

Which two woodwind instruments dont use reeds?

Recorders, like flutes, don’t have reeds but make a sound by splitting air across a sharp edge. Playing the recorder gives a very good introduction to the woodwind family but it is not just a ‘starter’ instrument.



What is a brass instrument without valves?

The trombone is the only instrument in the brass family that uses a slide instead of valves to change pitch. A standard trombone is made of long thin brass pipes.

Does a trumpet have a reed?

Do Any Instruments in the Brass Family use a Reed? No, brass instruments use a different attachment called a mouthpiece, which is a metal cup-shaped attachment that goes onto the receiver, an empty pipe on the end of the instrument closest to the face.

Does a piccolo have a reed?

Two reeds tied together are commonly known as a double reed. This double reed fits into a tube at the top of the instrument and vibrates when air is forced between the two reeds. The piccolo is exactly like the flute except that it is much smaller and is usually made of silver or wood.



Do saxophones have reeds?

Making sound by vibrating the reed
The sound of a saxophone is generated by vibrating the reed attached to the mouthpiece, which the player puts in his mouth. Instruments that make sound in this way are called reed instruments. The oboe and clarinet are also members of the reed instrument family.

Does a clarinet have a reed?

The clarinet is a single reed instrument. Made from wood, the clarinet produces a fluid sound when air is blown between a single reed and the mouthpiece. By pressing metal keys with the fingers of both hands, the player has the ability to play many different notes very quickly.

Do saxophones have spit valves?

Like brass instruments, the bodies of saxophones are made of metal. They’re often brass plated in another metal, such as nickel, silver or gold. Two types of saxophones—baritone and contrabass—have something else in common with brass instruments. Like trumpets and trombones, they have a spit valve.

Can you play a saxophone without a reed?

A saxophone is useless without a reed, other than perhaps as a fancy but inconveniently oversized paper weight. You need to get some reeds if you actually want to play some music or make a noise with your sax. So – the best place to start getting a reed is by looking at your feet.



Which is easier sax or trumpet?

Short-term the saxophone is probably easier for most. Trumpet is definitely more painful and disrupts the embouchure more. However, it’s by no means comfortable for saxophone players either.

Why is saxophone so loud?

A very common issue is only being able to play loud because your mouthpiece is way too far in your mouth. You can find a position which is good for playing loud as well as soft and at the same time producing the most pleasant sound by first trying the extremes and their effect: Mouthpiece too far in.