What specific advantages are there for writing the melody first vs the harmony first?



Asked by: Pete Juley

Is it better to write harmony or melody first?





The Melody Should Outline The Harmony



As a beginner composer, it is important to be specific about what you write. The reason for this is you are still learning the craft. Practicing specificity in the music you compose teaches you an important thing, how not to be ambiguous.

Is it better to write chords or melody first?

You can almost always tell the songs that started with chords: the melodies tend to sit around one or two notes as the chords change underneath. By focusing first on melody, you are more likely to imagine more interesting melodic shapes, including leaps, a climactic high point, and a better use of vocal range.

What is more important melody or harmony?

Therefore, the question of which is the more significant, melody or harmony, is futile. Beyond doubt, the means is subordinate to the end. Simplified, melody is the tune. It’s what you usually remember and can sing after hearing a musical piece.

When should you choose between the harmony and the melody?

Harmonies have two or more sounds played simultaneously, and the result should be sonically pleasing, and the sounds should complement one another. The main difference between harmonies and melodies is that a harmony builds upon an already existing melody, and a harmony needs a melody to exist.

How do you write melody first?





How to Write a Melody: 9 Tips for Writing Memorable Melodies

  1. Follow chords. …
  2. Follow a scale. …
  3. Write with a plan. …
  4. Give your melodies a focal point. …
  5. Write stepwise lines with a few leaps. …
  6. Repeat phrases, but change them slightly. …
  7. Experiment with counterpoint. …
  8. Put down your instrument.

Why is it important to understand melody?

A good melody will capture and hold your listener’s attention. Songwriters and composers use melodies in your music tell stories and give audiences something to remember and connect with. Songwriters and composers use melodies in your music tell stories and give audiences something to remember and connect with.

How do you write harmony for melody?

So what do we do with it well this is an example of what's called a non harmonic tone in this case a passing note and the simplest thing to do here is to follow the melody shape.

How do you write a melody without chords?

Go. You just play the f. Note. Okay so your when you simplify it to the bone. It's just this. Now on these you can sing. Those are not chords it's not d minor f it's just the e not just the f. Note.

How do you write melodies over chords?

How to write a Melody over Chords



  1. Strike a chord. In basic terms, a chord is made up of multiple notes, played simultaneously. …
  2. Pass it on. Tension might not sound like something you want in a melody, but it’s often the key to success. …
  3. New World Order. Watch the above video again. …
  4. You hum it, I’ll play it. …
  5. Roll the dice.


Why is harmony important in music?

Although it’s possible to have music without harmony, it is an element of music that helps develop the depth and the general tone of the piece, so it’s very important for students to grasp early. Harmony occurs in music when two or more pitches are sounded together at the same time.

Does melody or harmony give greater depth to music?

The harmony can come above and below the melody, and that will make the melody sound a lot richer. These alterations that are made to the context of the melody give the song a lot more depth.



How does harmony affect music?

Harmony is based on a melody. Melody is the main tonal phrase in a song, while harmony serves to complement the melody with different notes. In terms of different types of singing , the melody is often sung by soprano singers, while alto singers take over the harmony in most cases.

What is melody writing?

Melodies are a sequence of notes. They use different pitches and rhythms. They usually contain a balance of repetition and variety. A simple melody will use only notes from the key that a piece is in. A key is a set of notes that work well together.

What are two most important elements you need to consider in creating a simple melody?

The elements in creating a simple melody are staff, notes and rests, time signature, key signature, scale, home tone and lyrics. creating simple lyrics for a melody.

How will you improve your skills in creating simple melodies?

Here’s a short list of ideas that will hopefully help you out:



  1. Create your chords, record them, and let them sit in your mind for several days. …
  2. Change how you play your chords. …
  3. Choose a good progression, but don’t stop experimenting. …
  4. Explore vocal range.


What makes an effective melody?

Listeners should be hearing certain melodic intervals, rhythms and other musical shapes repeating throughout the melody. Most good melodies are comprised of stepwise motion (i.e., move by scale steps), with occasional leaps. Melodies that are too leapy are often too difficult to sing.

How can you improve learners ability to appreciate music?

Play pieces of music and then give them a chance to describe what the piece made them think about. Encourage them to tell what they could feel, taste, smell, hear, and see in their mind. Getting students to think critically is one goal in education. Making this relevant is sometimes a challenge.

How can I improve my music writing skills?

Great songwriters use these ten practical tips when composing new music and lyrics.



  1. Compose a catchy melody. …
  2. Use all types of chords. …
  3. Create a memorable rhythm. …
  4. Build your song around a riff. …
  5. Write a song you can play live. …
  6. Step away from your instrument to write. …
  7. Get ambitious with song structure.

How do I write a song for my girlfriend?

Focus on a story, not an emotion.



A song that’s just about how much you love someone will leave your listener wondering why. Think of a story about your boyfriend or girlfriend that explains how you feel about them. Write down all the ideas you can think of and pick the one you like best.