Western vs Indian Carnatic style of violin playing?



Asked by: Kristy Pace

Is Carnatic violin different from western violin?





The basic instrument can be same to play both western music as well as carnatic music. However the way strings are tuned for Carnatic and Western music is different in terms of scale.

Is Carnatic or Western violin better?

I would personally recommend Carnatic Violin as the fingering styles are a bit tough to learn. But once you ace it… you can have both carnatic and western easily. Learning Western violin is bit easy. But will be tough later to learn carnatic.

Can we play Western music on Carnatic violin?

Yes, you can. You can notate and play solo, but it will be difficult to perform in a band. This is because in western music concerts, it is common for the pitch to change between songs, or sometimes even increase midway between two stanzas.

What is the difference between Western violin and Indian violin?

Western instruments tend to be on the lighter side being built from softwoods like spruce. Indian violins are made from hardwoods and are noticeably heavier. The second major difference is the pitch of the music. The western violin tends to be on a higher pitch while Indian violins are deeper.

What is Carnatic violin?





The Carnatic violin is played sitting cross-legged, the instrument pointing to the ground with the scroll resting firmly on the ankle of the player’s right foot. This allows the left hand to slide freely up and down the neck. The aim of tone production in violin is to imitate the Carnatic vocal style.

Why is violin used in Carnatic music?

The instrument was soon found to be ideal for playing classical Indian music because it lends itself well to its melodic subtleties. Today, it is rare to find a performance of Carnatic music without the violin. Breaking with European tradition, Indian violinists sit cross-legged and hold their instrument vertically.

Which is more difficult Carnatic or Hindustani?

While Carnatic music lays a lot of emphasis on composition and lyrics, Hindustani lays a lot of stress on the plain notes (swaras).

Who created Carnatic violin?

musician Baluswami Dikshitar

The history of the violin in South India goes back further than the 17th-century musician Baluswami Dikshitar — the first known violinist to infuse the instrument into Carnatic music.



How much does a violin cost in India?

Questions & Answers on Violin

Product Name Average Price in Rs.
3 Strings Violin ₹ 5500 per piece
4 Strings Violin ₹ 3500 per piece
5 Strings Violin ₹ 12500 per piece

Is violin used in Indian music?

Today, the violin is not only ubiquitous in Carnatic music, but has also become a popular instrument among North Indian classical (Hindustani) musicians.



How is the violin played in India?

In the western classical tradition, the violin is supported between the chin and shoulder. In the Indian classical tradition, music is almost always performed cross legged on the floor. So the violin too is is held by the performer when they are seated on the floor.

Is violin a Western instrument?

Violins are important instruments in a wide variety of musical genres. They are most prominent in the Western classical tradition, both in ensembles (from chamber music to orchestras) and as solo instruments.
Violin.

String instrument
Developed Early 16th century
Playing range
Related instruments

Which musical instrument from India is similar to a violin?

The sarod is a plucked stringed instrument with a skin-covered resonator and sympathetic strings.

Who is the best violinist in India?

Dr. L. Subramaniam, India’s most famous violinist who performed at UCLA’s Fowler Museum.



What is the hardest instrument to play?

The 11 Hardest Musical Instruments to Learn

  • Violin. The violin is a wooden stringed instrument that’s part of a larger family of similar instruments. …
  • The French Horn. …
  • The Organ. …
  • Bagpipes. …
  • Accordion. …
  • Oboe. …
  • Harp. …
  • Guitar.

Why is violin so hard?

The true difficulty of violin playing lies in executing the bow strokes with precision. A violinist must simultaneously control the angle of the bow and pressure applied to its hair. If you add only a tiny bit too much pressure, you will hear a scratching sound.

Why is violin the hardest instrument?

Though it only has four strings, the violin is considered one of the most difficult stringed instruments to master. There are several reasons for this. For starters, unlike the guitar, there are no frets on the violin. Finger position is learned through trial and error as well as the guidance of a skilled teacher.