Does a melody (which will be used with chords) need to have the notes in the same scale?



Asked by: Amber Liu

Do melodies have to be in the same scale?





It’s definitely not “the rule”, in the sense that you have to follow it – there are no rules that you have to follow. And there are songs where the harmony and melody seem to at least partly work like the other way you described – where it seems like the scale for the melody can potentially change on each chord change.

Do chords have to be in the same scale?

In your average chord progression, most of the time all of the notes will stay in the scale that correlates with the key of your song. If the song is in G major, your chords will contain notes that are found in that scale- G major, C major, D major, E minor, A minor, B minor.

Can you use different chords under the same melody?

The simplest example is the pair of enharmonic chords (Maj 6, relative min 7). For example in the key of C (C6, A-7) are the exact same chord just different inversions. There are other pairs. This allows you the composer to create much more interesting harmonies for the same melody (and this is a very common practice).

How do you match a melody to chords?

So what you want to do once you've figured out the key is determine what those chords would be in that key c is our one count up four from c you've got our four which is f count up five you've got g.

Does melody have to follow chords?





Got chords, want melody



Now you know the key and the notes you can play in that key. Try to move in this key, first follow the chords. Deviate from the chords and try to make it sound good. Unfortunately, there really is no recipe for writing melodies.

Can you play scales in any order?

It cannot be just any group of notes in any order, because even playing a scale down changes the distances between the notes. For example, a major scales has the following pattern of whole steps and half steps: W W H W W W H. That is the ascending pattern.

How do scales work with chords?

Simply put, a chord scale is revealed when you build a chord on each degree of a scale, using related tones from within that scale. For example, the major scale has seven degrees, and we can therefore build seven chords from that scale, one chord rooted on each degree.

How chords and scales work together?

Scales and chords are interrelated. There are two sides of the same coin. A scale is a horizontal representation of a particular collection of notes and is built up in 2nds; A chord is a vertical representation of that same collection of notes and is built in 3rds.

Are chords based on scales?

The Major and Minor scales are the foundation for most chords. By knowing the Major Scale and the (Natural) Minor Scale you will be able to envision a large part of all chords. Chords are constructed by tones that are included in these scales and ordered by certain intervals.



Do you write melody or chords first?

A melody-first songwriting process implies that the first step in our music composition is to compose a melody and once we have a significant of it done, we can start putting chords to it.

Do songs need chord progression?

But the short answer is no. A piece of music can have no chord changes if that works for you.

What makes a good melody?

Most good melodies are comprised of stepwise motion (i.e., move by scale steps), with occasional leaps. Melodies that are too leapy are often too difficult to sing. Good writers use melodic leaps as a good way to generate little shots of energy. Most good melodies have a discernible relationship with the bass line.



How do you write a melody without chords?

Go. You just play the f. Note. Okay so your when you simplify it to the bone. It's just this. Now on these you can sing. Those are not chords it's not d minor f it's just the e not just the f. Note.

How do I make a song melody?

How to Write a Melody: 9 Tips for Writing Memorable Melodies

  1. Follow chords. …
  2. Follow a scale. …
  3. Write with a plan. …
  4. Give your melodies a focal point. …
  5. Write stepwise lines with a few leaps. …
  6. Repeat phrases, but change them slightly. …
  7. Experiment with counterpoint. …
  8. Put down your instrument.

Can you be a songwriter without singing?

Most songwriters can manage to sing more-or-less in tune, even if their voice is shaky, or the tuning isn’t spot-on. If you don’t consider yourself a singer, here are the ways in which your voice tends to let you down when you try to use it.